Jim's column 4.4.2020

My request for questions from readers generated loads of questions and it will take me several weeks to answer all of them. So here we go:

David Whitlock: 'Is it true that Coventry City played against the great Brazilian, Pele, in the 1970s.

The Sky Blues toured South East Asia in the close season of 1972. They played two games in South Korea against national select Xis, winning 2-0 and 3-2, before moving to Japan where they played three games in seven days. Again they played select elevens, winning two games and losing one. The tour ended in Bangkok where a friendly was organised with legendary Brazilian club side Santos. The game was played in heavy rain and the teams played out a 2-2 draw in front of 32,000. Alan Green and Quintin Young scored for City with Edu and a Pele penalty netting for Santos. I don't have the line-ups for that game but from pictures I know that Roy Barry, Willie Carr, Ernie Hunt and Chris Chilton also played that day. The picture shows City players Alan Dugdale and Hunt holding up Pele's number 10 shirt. 'Duggy', who had yet to make his senior debut at the time, was voted man of the match and asked the great man for his shirt. It was kept at his parent's home in Kirby on Merseyside for some years and, according to Alan's brother Dave, local fans flocked to the house to have a picture taken with it. At some point, Alan collected it and eventually took it to Hong Kong where it is believed he donated it to the Bulova club where he was playing at the time.

                                   

                                                Alan Dugdale (left) and Ernie Hunt with Pele's shirt

Deejay2000: I’ve always been interested in Oggy's long unbroken stint in goal for City. Any interesting facts about that. It would be interesting to know how many keepers have kept goal for City since he last played for us.

After signing from Shrewsbury Town in 1984 and making his debut at Villa Park, Oggy played 246 consecutive games (209 league, 29 Cup, 8 others) before getting injured at Millwall in Sept 1989. Another legendary City goalkeeper, Alf Wood, always pointed out he had made 260 consecutive games between 1945-51. However the 1945-46 season is not counted as an official first class season and his total is actually 218.

During Oggy's time as a player (1984-2000) ten other keepers played in first team: Keith Waugh (2), Clive Baker (1), Steve Sutton (1), Paul Heald (2), Les Sealey (2), Jonathan Gould (26), John Filan (17), Magnus Hedman (87), Rafaele Nuzzo (1), Chris Kirkland (1). Since Oggy retired in 2000, a further 32 goalkeepers have played first class games including two who made only one appearance, Michael Quirke & Danny Ireland.

David Collins: When and where did Dion Dublin score his last goal for Coventry City?

Dion's last goal for the club came in his final game for the Sky Blues at Southampton on 24 October 1998 in a 2-1 defeat. Matt Le Tissier and Egil Ostenstad gave Saints a 2-0 half-time lead and Dion reduced the arrears on 61 minutes. City's line-up was very strong: Hedman: Nilsson (sub Edworthy), Burrows (sub Telfer), Boateng (sub Soltvedt), Breen, Shaw, Whelan, McAllister, Dublin, Huckerby, Froggatt. The attendance was 15,152. Three days later City went to Luton for a League Cup tie and Dion, with a transfer to Villa on the cards, allegedly refused to play. He had to wait over a week for his Villa debut, a 3-2 win over Tottenham, but proved an instant hit by scoring two first half goals as Villa retained top spot in the Premier League.

Mark from Birmingham: Have Coventry ever been top of a division longer than the current run?

Mark has his tongue in his cheek with this one. The club record for number of days at the top of any division is 158 days set in 1963-64 when the Sky Blues were champions of Division Three. City went top on 8th October 1963 with a 2-1 home win over Bristol City and stayed in pole position until Saturday 14th March when Crystal Palace overhauled them the day after City had lost 5-2 at home to Southend United. On 3rd January they had a nine-point lead at the top which was slowly whittled away during an 11-game run without a victory. The Sky Blues regained top spot briefly on 11th April before slipping behind Palace again but on the final day they returned to top spot with a 1-0 home win over Colchester as Palace slipped up by losing at home to Oldham.

Jim's column 28.3.2020

With football suspended and little current stuff to write about I thought I would take the opportunity to answer some recent readers' queries and questions. If you have a question about Coventry City's history or statistics please get in contact, either by email clarriebourton@gmail.com or on twitter @clarriebourton and I will try and answer you.

First up is Keith Ballantyne, a regular correspondent. In December, after the victory at Ipswich in the FA Cup replay, I wrote about City's poor record in away replays in the competition (it was only the fifth win in 31 replays). Keith wanted to know if there was a similar poor record in League Cup replays.

The format of the League Cup (inaugurated in 1960) has always been different to the FA Cup and there have been no replays since 1996. There have also been less opportunities for replays because until 2000 the First and second rounds were two-legged. I can find only five instances where the Sky Blues had away replays in the competition:-

1965-66 West Brom lost 6-1 (after 1-1 draw)

1968-69 Swindon lost 3-0 (after 2-2 draw)

1973-74 Manchester City lost 4-2 (after 2-2 draw)

1980-81 Cambridge United won 1-0 (after 1-1 draw)

1985-86 West Brom lost 4-3 (after 0-0 draw)

Only one win in five therefore, an unimpressive record. One interesting stat however is that in the first three occurrences the team that knocked City out went on to reach the final with West Brom and Swindon both lifting the trophy. It is disappointing to think that we'll never see another League Cup replay with the rules now ensuring ties are settled at the first time of asking.

The legendary George Hudson celebrated his 83rd birthday last week and Barry Allsopp asked me to settle an argument about the former City centre-forward. Barry thought George was born, or grew-up, in Accrington but his friend thinks he was born in Manchester and that Blackburn was his first professional club.

I'm afraid your friend is correct Barry. George was born in Manchester and his first club was Blackburn Rovers. He joined Rovers as 20 year-old in 1958 and made his debut in a 2-1 win over Manchester City in April 1959. After four appearances and one goal he was released by Rovers and signed for Fourth Division Accrington Stanley. After an inauspicious debut (Stanley lost 9-2 at Crystal Palace) he set the division alight with 35 goals in 44 games and after just 12 games he was sold to Peterborough United for a sizeable fee. He played alongside Terry Bly (the man he would ultimately displace at Coventry) and over the next eighteen months scored 50 goals in 75 games. In April 1963 Jimmy Hill splashed out a club record £21,000 to bring the prolific scorer to Highfield Road. A hat-trick on his Sky Blues debut (the only man ever to do this) made him an instant hero and his 28 goals in 36 games was a major factor in the club's 1963-64 promotion success. It's hard to believe that George was only at the club for three years but managed 75 goals in 129 games. On transfer deadline day in 1966 JH shocked the fans by agreeing to sell 'The Hud', as he was known, to First Division Northampton Town for £30,000. He failed to keep the Cobblers in the top flight and within a year was on the move to Tranmere Rovers where injuries meant he was unable to maintain a regular place in the team. He did come back to haunt the Sky Blues however, in 1968 when he netted in Rovers' shock 2-0 FA Cup win over City.

Finally, Clive Baskerville pointed out that in 1964 the champions of the top three divisions were Liverpool, Leeds United and Coventry City. If we ever see the end of this season it would be a massive coincidence to be looking at the same champions at 56 years ago. Division Four, that season, was won by Gillingham, but as they are in League One the full set can't be replicated.

Jim's column 22.3.2020

The Coronavirus and subsequent suspension of professional football has brought Coventry City's surge to promotion from League One to a shuddering halt. Football pales into insignificance to people's health but Sky Blues' fans will still be concerned about the outcome of the 2019-20 season and whether the campaign will be seen through to a satisfactory conclusion. City's final game before the suspension two weeks ago was another away victory, at Ipswich, and the seventh win on the road in eight since Christmas Day. Portman Road has always been a difficult ground for City and before this season they had only won twice there in 29 league visits stretching back to the early seventies. Now we have won twice there in three months!

The away form since Christmas has been the difference between City being a top six side hoping for a play-off place and being league leaders and promotion favourites with the bookies. To put it into context, Jimmy Hill's 1967 promotion team only won six away games in the whole season.

If and when the season re-commences there are a number of club records that Mark Robins' team may threaten in the final ten games. At the moment the team have lost only three league games all season, one at home (Tranmere) and two away (Rotherham and Shrewsbury). The club record for the lowest number of defeats in a season is six, set in the1963-64 Division Three championship season (46 games) and equalled in the 1966-67 Division Two season (42 games). The fewest home defeats in a season is one, achieved in 1935-36, 1946-47, 1958-59 and 1966-67 (three of those seasons were promotion campaigns). The fewest away defeats in a season is five, again set in 1966-67, and this is one record that the team might threaten.

The other record well within their sights is a record points total. Since three points was introduced for a win in 1981 the highest number of points is 75, set by Robins' team in reaching the play-offs two years ago. With a current total of 67 a new record is well within their sights. If pre-1981 points' totals are recalculated on a three points basis the best ever season was 1958-59 in Division Four when 84 points would have been won from a 46-game season. The next best was 82 in 1963-64 and 1966-67.

One record which won't be broken this season is the incredible unbeaten league run of Jimmy Hill's 1966-67 team. After losing at Huddersfield in November the Sky Blues went 25 games unbeaten until the end of the season. The current run is 14 unbeaten and the team can only reach 24 this campaign. That 1967 run did however include an FA Cup defeat to Newcastle and the club's record run in all competitions is a more modest 22, set in the weather battered 1962-63 season. That campaign, Jimmy Hill's first full season in charge, the Sky Blues lost a League Cup tie at Portsmouth in October and then remained unbeaten in 22 league and FA Cup games before Manchester United lowered City's colours in the FA Cup quarter finals on the last Saturday in March. Robins' team have now gone 18 unbeaten (counting the Blues' Cup loss as a draw) and are only four away from the record.

Mark Robins deservedly won the League One Manager of the Month award for February and became the first Coventry City manager to win three awards. The team's results during the month were nothing short of spectacular with five wins and one draw and the draw coming against the then league leaders. Mark's previous awards with City were in December 2012 and October 2018 and he has also won awards with Rotherham (twice) and Scunthorpe. The only other City manager to win more than one award was Gordon Strachan who won in December 1996 and February 1998.

I have to report the passing two weeks ago of a close friend, Geoff Moore. Geoff, a former pupil of Bablake and Liverpool University who taught Chemistry at Lawrence Sheriff School in Rugby, had followed the Sky Blues from the 1960s. He was a proud member of the 92 Club (he achieved that at Cheltenham two years ago) and had watched the Sky Blues play at all current 91 clubs except Macclesfield and Salford. His first away ground was Swindon's County Ground for an FA Cup third round tie in 1966 and since then has seen City play on 118 different English grounds not including both Wembley Stadiums, Sutton United and Motherwell in Scotland where he attended a Texaco Cup game in the 1970s.. Geoff kept a lot of quirky stats about City including a spreadsheet of the average age of every City team that ever played and the number of players of different nationalities that played at the Ricoh. His football friends will hugely miss his company in Coventry hostelries (he always found the right place for a pre-game drink!) and in the stands at the Ricoh and St Andrews. I am sure all who knew Geoff send their condolences to his wife Jackie and sons Andrew and Chris who are both massive City fans. RIP Geoff.

Jim's column 21.2.2020

I try and keep an eye on former Coventry City players and follow their careers. Last week Colin Heys came up with one I wasn't aware of, Ruben Lameiras, who is back in his home country of Portugal playing for Famalicao. Ruben left Coventry in the summer of 2017 after making 69 appearances for the club including the EFL Trophy final in 2017 and joined Plymouth Argyle. After suffering relegation from League One with the Sky Blues that season he endured another torrid season last year with Argyle which saw the Pilgrims relegated to League Two.

Despite being offered a new deal at Home Park, Ruben decided to move to the Portuguese side who were promoted to the top flight for the first time in 25 years and it seems that he is making a success of things as Colin points out that World Soccer magazine have identified him as 'one to watch'. Famalicao are doing remarkable well too, lying in sixth place in the Primeira Liga and through to the Cup semi finals for the first time in their history, not bad for a club whose stadium holds just over 5,000.

Another former City player who came across my radar recently is Phillipe Clement who is managing Belgian league leaders Club Brugge who played Manchester United in the Europa League this week. Phillipe spent one unhappy, injury-ridden season at Coventry in 1998-99 having joined from Genk and made just 16 appearances, eight of them from the bench before returning to his homeland to play for Club Brugge. His injury problems cleared up after his move and he went on to make over 300 appearances for Brugge in the next 10 years as well as winning 38 full caps for his country. He's still relatively new at the management game but led Genk to a surprise league title last season and was lured away to Brugge who currently lead the Belgian League by 11 points.

                                                                Philippe Clement                     

Nearer to home, National League side Barrow are seven points clear at the top of the table and look favourites to gain promotion to the Football League after almost 50 years in non-league. They lost their place in the league in 1972 in times when the bottom four sides in the old Division Four had to seek re-election in a vote with the best non-league sides. That year Barrow were unfortunate to face, in the vote, Hereford United, who had captured the nation's hearts with their FA Cup exploits earlier that year. Poor old Barrow lost out and have never got near returning to the league until this season. They are managed by Cov kid Ian Evatt, who played almost 600 senior games for Derby, Northampton, Chesterfield, QPR and Blackpool including a season in the Premier League with the Seasiders. Ian, in his first full-time management role, is supported by his assistant, former City defender Peter Atherton who made 120 appearances for the Sky Blues in the early 1990s. Another at barrow with a Coventry connection is striker Dior Angus, son of former Nuneaton, Northampton and Fulham defender Terry Angus.

                                                                        Peter Atherton

Colin Heys also alerted to me to the fact that former Coventry loanee Chuba Akpom is a star in Greece with PAOK Salonika. He left Arsenal in 2018 to join the Greek side and was a member of the team that won the domestic double last season with Chuba scoring the winner in the Cup final. He is a regular again this season and has appeared in the UEFA Champions League.

Jim's column 15.2.2020

Two home wins in four days have lifted the Sky Blues up to third place in League One a position they were last placed on 1st January after the 4-1 victory at Tranmere. The victories over Bolton and Portsmouth mean the team are unbeaten in nine league games (including seven wins) and thirteen games in all competitions. The latter run is the club's best since 1998 when Gordon Strachan's side combined a strong second half of the Premiership with a fabulous FA Cup run including victories at Liverpool and Aston Villa. The FA Cup run came to an unlucky end in a penalty shoot-out at Bramall Lane but the unbeaten run went on for a further two games before Villa got their revenge with a 2-1 league win at Highfield Road.

The club record for an unbeaten run in all competitions is always assumed to be the 1966-67 promotion team who, of course, went 25 games unbeaten in winning the Second Division title. However that team lost an FA Cup third round tie to Newcastle in the middle of the fantastic league run and their best unbeaten run in league and cup games was 15 from the cup defeat until the end of the season. The club record can be found in another Jimmy Hill season, 1962-63. After losing 5-1 at Portsmouth in a League Cup tie on 17th October, the Sky Blues remained unbeaten in all games until 30th March when Manchester United won the FA Cup sixth round tie at Highfield Road – a total of 22 games (14 in Division Three and eight in the FA Cup). That was the winter of the big freeze and because of postponements caused by weather or FA Cup commitments they were left having to play 16 league games in seven weeks and their promotion push fizzled out and they finished fourth in the table.

This current team's performances reminds me so much of the 1966-67 campaign, especially since Christmas. Narrow home wins and late goals were a feature of that promotion campaign after Christmas. JH's team, like the current side, had two convincing victories at Christmas, beating Rotherham 4-2 and Portsmouth 5-1, but then struggled to overcome sides at home. The next seven home league games went as follows:

14th January Norwich won 2-1 (Ernie Machin scores 89th minute winner)

11th February Preston won 2-1 (Machin and Bobby Gould score in last 10 minutes)

25th February Carlisle won 2-1 (Machin scores 88th minute winner)

18th March Bolton drew 1-1 (City concede 87th minute equaliser)

28th March Northampton won 2-0 (City only secure victory with Gould's 83rd minute goal)

1st April Derby drew 2-2 (Machin scores 80th minute equaliser)

15th April Huddersfield won 1-0 (Gould's second half goal in a scrappy win)

Ironically, in the next home game against their fiercest rivals Wolves, the Sky Blues turned on the style and won 3-1.

In between these home results the team remained unbeaten away with three wins and five draws with all three victories by the odd goal). Older fans may remember that season with fond memories but it was hard going with results, at home and away, ground out every week. Several opposition managers criticised City's physical approach to games with Bob Stokoe of Charlton describing City as the dirtiest side he had seen.

The point I am trying to make is that City's great 1967 team didn't thrash the opposition every week, they fought hard, never gave up and remained unbeaten even when they didn't play well and relied on an outstanding home record with only one defeat at Highfield Road all season. Does that remind you of Mark Robins' current team?

Jim's column 8.2.2020

Coventry City's FA Cup run came to a dramatic end on Tuesday evening with a penalty shoot-out going 4-1 in Birmingham's favour but the plaudits going to the Sky Blues for their performance. But for the late goals in the 92nd minute and 120th minutes we would be planning a trip to Leicester in round five. I suppose the positive way of looking at things is that the team can concentrate on the promotion race which couldn't be tighter. Today's home game with Bolton and Tuesday night's six-pointer with in-form Portsmouth are crucial and a bounce-back after Tuesday night is vital.

The game on Tuesday night was City's seventh in the competition and equalled the most FA Cup games in a season since 1962-63 when City reached the quarter finals as a Third Division side and played nine games. City's extra-time record in the competition isn't great – they haven't won after extra-time since the Wembley final in 1987. Since that memorable victory over Tottenham they have now lost four extra-time ties:

1994-95 v Norwich City (a) 1-3 (after 1-1 draw)

1997-98 v Sheffield United (a) 1-1 (after 1-1 draw) (City lost on penalties)

2009-10 V Portsmouth (h) 1-2 (after 1-1 draw)

2019-20 v Birmingham (a) 2-2 (after 0-0 draw) (City lost on penalties)

In total City have now gone to extra-time in 15 FA Cup ties, stretching back to 1908, and have won only three times, at Derby in 1974, the 1987 semi-final against Leeds and the final against Tottenham. In the days before penalty shoot-outs City survived extra-time and went on to play second replays on four occasions, progressing three times, the last time in 1984 v Wolves in the Third round.

The League Cup is a much younger competition and since its conception in 1960 City have played extra-time on nine occasions and have a better record. They have won after extra-time six times including once in a penalty shoot-out (at Peterborough in 2001).

I had an interesting enquiry from the Southampton historian this week concerning former City player George Lowrie. Born in Tonypandy, South Wales in 1919, George was on Second Division Swansea's books as a teenager and made his first-team debut as a 17-year-old in 1937. First Division Preston spotted his potential and just over a year later he moved to Deepdale. He played five games for Preston before Harry Storer signed him for Coventry in June 1939, two months before war broke out in Europe. His City debut took place on the day before was broke out and he netted in a 4-2 Second Division win over Barnsley before the season was aborted.

During the war he guested for Bristol City, Nottingham Forest and Northampton as well as playing in a good number of unofficial games for City and his goalscoring exploits earned him four wartime Welsh caps. When official league football restarted in 1946, having effectively lost seven years of his career, he must have been like a coiled spring. He scored freely in an average City team with five hat-tricks including three in successive home games in a total of 29 in league and FA Cup in 36 games. He carried that form into 1947-48 and by early March 1948 had netted 18 goals in 22 games. Transfer rumours abounded as the deadline approached and his final City game was in a 1-0 home defeat to Southampton. That was on the Saturday and on the Wednesday he appeared for Wales against Northern Ireland at Wrexham. On the Thursday Newcastle's manager and director were in Coventry negotiating his move to the Second Division team. Newcastle were cash-rich from average crowds of almost 50,000 and under the regulations in those days couldn't offset ground improvements against a punitive tax rate but could spend their profits on players. As a result City held out for £20,000, the second highest British transfer fee at that time.

                                                 City's 1947-48 team with Lowrie seated at front

Having played his final City game against Southampton, Lowrie made his Newcastle debut at the Dell two days later, with Saints winning 4-2 (thus the interest from the Saints' historian). He scored only one goal in his first five games before suffering a serious knee injury. Newcastle won promotion and Lowrie returned to the team the following season but made only seven more appearances over eighteen months before joining Bristol City for £10,000. He partly rediscovered his goal touch in the Third Division before making a sentimental return to Highfield Road in 1952 to try and save City from relegation from Division Two. He managed three goals in 12 games but couldn't keep City up. After less than half a season in the lower division George, now 33, moved back to South Wales to play for non-league Lovells Athletic. His incredible goalscoring ratio, 59 goals in 85 games, is bettered by only one other City player, the legendary Clarrie Bourton.

Jim's column 1.2.2020

The games are coming thick and fast for the Sky Blues and February promises to be a crucial month with seven first-team games including today's match at Bristol Rovers. Home games against fellow promotion contenders Portsmouth and Rotherham are real six-pointers and City need to keep their momentum up with hopefully less draws and more victories.

What a great atmosphere at St Andrews last week for the cup-tie and it promises to be similar on Tuesday night under the lights in the replay. The attendance at last week's game was restricted due to safety and police guidance but numbered a healthy 21,193. There were 11,728 Coventry fans, the highest number to watch the team outside Coventry other than at Wembley since the FA Cup semi-final at Hillsborough in 1987 when 25,000 were present. The Blues contingent was impressive too – with 9,465 'away' fans the largest away following at a City game since Highfield Road was made all-seater in 1981. Earlier that year there were an estimated 10,000 West Ham fans for the first leg of the League Cup semi-final.

Coventry City will be playing their seventh game in this season's FA Cup on Tuesday night – the most they have played in the competition in a single season since the famous 1963 run when the club played nine games in reaching the Quarter Finals as a Third Division club. That season their games were as follows:-

Round 1 Bournemouth (h) 1-0

Round 2 Millwall (a) 0-0

replay Millwall (h) 2-1

Round 3 Lincoln City (a) 5-1

Round 4 Portsmouth (a) 1-1

replay Portsmouth (h) 2-2

2nd replay Portsmouth* 2-1

Round 5 Sunderland (h) 2-1

Round 6 Manchester United (h) 1-3

*second replay at White Hart Lane

The drawn game against Birmingham meant that the club have had three successive ties with replays something that has only happened once before, in 1974. That season City beat Sheffield Wednesday 3-1 in round three after a 0-0 draw at Hillsborough, beat Derby 1-0 after a 0-0 draw at Highfield Road but lost in round five, 3-2 at QPR, after a 0-0 draw at Coventry.

After the Blues cup game I had the pleasure of meeting former City player Jim Hagan who was over in the UK for a rare visit from his home in Southern Spain. Jim, now aged 63, made only nineteen appearances for the Sky Blues between 1978-82 before joining Birmingham and playing over 150 games for the Bluenoses. A central defender, most of Jim's games in Sky Blue came in 1978-79 when he stood in for Gary Gillespie and partnered Jim Holton at the back. The Northern Irishman went to Torquay on loan in 1979-80 and then had spells with Seiko in Hong Kong and Jimmy Hill's US teams, Detroit Express and Washington Diplomats. He returned to Highfield Road in 1981 and was a regular in the reserves but couldn't win a regular first team place because of the form of Gillespie and Paul Dyson. His final game for the club was an FA Cup sixth round defeat at West Brom in March 1982 and he moved to St Andrews that summer. I managed to introduce him to CCFPA president Kirk Stephens and they discovered they have homes a few miles apart on the Costa Del Sol. Another reunion occurred with Harry Roberts (another who played for both the Sky Blues and the Blues) and the two reminisced about lift sharing to Birmingham in the 1980s.

                           

                                                                 Jim Hagan receiving his CCFPA tie