Ernie Machin R.I.P

Ernie Machin

Born Walkden 26 April 1944

Died Coventry 22 July 2012

It is sad to report the death of Coventry City legend Ernie Machin who passed away in Coventry on Sunday aged 68.

Ernie made 289 appearances for the Sky Blues, scoring 39 goals and will be remembered for taking over the club captaincy from another legend George Curtis in 1967 when George suffered a broken leg.  His inspiring leadership on the pitch was a key factor in City surviving relegation in their first two seasons in the top flight.

Born in Walkden, Manchester in April 1944, Ernie had trials alongside Alan Ball at Bolton but was not considered good enough. Instead he played for Nelson FC and was spotted by City's North West scout Alf Walton in 1962. Walton called Jimmy Hill and said 'you need to sign this boy up before others do' and Hill hot-footed north to watch Machin and was besotted before half-time. 

Hill recognised something special about Ernie. In his autobiography Hill describes watching the young Machin: ‘he looked extremely slow, but nevertheless when he was in possession of the ball he hardly wasted a pass. He didn’t seem to be an outstanding athlete, nor did he have the confidence or the luck to do something special …I said later that the real reason I took him on was because I liked the look in his eyes …. He had a bright eye and he said, ‘if you give me a chance, I won’t let you down’. Hill wasn’t going to pay  a huge fee for Ernie and offered the chairman of Nelson £50. To Hill’s amazement he agreed and ‘for decency’s sake’ he quickly added that if Ernie made the first team he would bump it up to £200.

His comment about his eyes was misinterpreted by many fans who called him ‘Jimmy’s blue-eyed boy’ especially when his form temporarily dipped after his return from injury.

After a year in the reserves Ernie got his first team chance in April 1963 as City's FA Cup heroes were ploughing through a fixture backlog owing to the Cup run and the worst winter of a generation. 18 year old Ernie deputised at inside-forward for a tired Jimmy Whitehouse and immediately impressed the Sky Blue faithful. He played alongside new signing, fellow Lancastrian George Hudson in a 2-0 win over Millwall.

Despite playing just six games the previous campaign Ernie was the first choice in the number 10 shirt from the start of the 1963-64 season and was outstanding as the team raced to the top of the Third Division and threatened to clinch promotion in a record time. Then in November in a home game with Watford he suffered a bad knee injury just days after England manager Alf Ramsey had told JH that Machin was on his radar for an under 23 call and missed the rest of City’s Third Division promotion campaign.

He ended up having several operations and it was eighteen months before he was fully recovered. He returned to play a pivotal role in the club’s charge to the Second Division title in 1967 and netted eleven goals including memorable late goals to get vital results against Norwich, Preston & Carlisle not to mention the first of City’s goals in the famous 3-1 victory over Wolves watched by over 51,000 at Highfield Road.

When skipper George Curtis broke his leg in the club’s second game in Division One there was only one candidate for the captaincy and Ernie, converted to an attacking wing-half, was proud to lead the team out. He missed only three games in those first two years of struggle and older fans will remember his stunning goal in the 2-0 victory over European champions elect Manchester United in March 1968. His never-say-die attitude won him the respect of all his playing colleagues and the fans. He continued to be a regular, when fit, right up to the time of his departure in 1972 but a bad car accident put him out for three months in 1970 and his ‘dodgy’ knee continued to trouble him.

In 1972 he became the first English football player to successfully challenge a fine and suspension by the Football Association in the courts. He was sent off in a game at Newcastle for allegedly kicking an opponent, however TV evidence showed that he was innocent; nevertheless the FA noticed something else which he had done and upheld the disciplinary action on the basis of that without allowing him to present a defence. The courts ruled against the FA, and the PFA subsequently established the rights of players to legal representation in disciplinary cases.

In December 1972 Ernie was sold to Plymouth Argyle for £35,000 by new bosses Joe Mercer and Gordon Milne keen to raise money to buy Tommy Hutchison and Colin Stein. He had ten great years at Highfield Road making 284 appearances and scoring 39 goals and but for injury would have reached the 400 mark.

After eighteen happy months at Plymouth where he helped them to the League Cup semi final in 1974 and became a cult hero, he had two years at Brighton. In 1977 Jimmy Hill, by now the chairman at Highfield Road, persuaded Ernie to return to Coventry City as youth team coach. It didn’t work out however and he left football and worked for Car Bodies and Massey Ferguson.

Ernie had suffered poor health for a number of years but he had attended a reunion of the 1967 promotion team in 2007 as well as the last two Legends' Days organised by the Former Players Association. In 2008 he was one of thirty former players inducted into the club's Legends Group for services to the football club.

The epithet Legend is a word used too often about mediocre players in the hyperbole-driven modern media however Ernie Machin was a true Coventry City Legend.

2011-12 Stats review

Coventry City had failed to finish higher than 17^th in any of the previous five seasons in the Championship. Therefore with a lack of investment and an over-reliance on promising but raw youngsters it was hardly surprising that the Sky Blues had a tough season which culminated in relegation to the third tier of English football for the first time since 1964.

Manager Andy Thorn who had lifted the gloom somewhat at the back end of 2010-11 had to manage without some of the key players he had inherited including King, Westwood, Turner, Gunnarsson and latterly Jutkiewicz. He also had no luck on the injury front with players like Clarke, Deegan, Wood, McPake, Cameron and Baker missing big slugs of the campaign.

Points: The team gathered only 40 points in finishing 23^rd (the lowest finishing position in the club’s history). Only once since three points for a win was introduced in 1981 has a Coventry team recorded less points, in 1995-96 under Ron Atkinson, but that was from only 38 games (and we weren’t relegated!). Under the pre-81 points system only 31 points would have been gained it wouldn’t have been the worst season ever – that was in 1919-20 when only 29 points were gained (from 42 games) and the club avoided re-election only through bribing their final day opponents.

Home Form: The home record was won 8, drew 7, lost 8. The goals scored (28) and conceded (26) were almost identical to 2010-11 (27-26)  – only the second positive home goal difference since 2006-07. Between Boxing Day and April the team lost only one home game in nine in their efforts to avoid relegation.

Away Form: The away form proved to be the Sky Blues’ undoing with only one win all season (at Hull at the end of March). They were the last of the 92 league clubs to register an away victory. The final record was won 1, drew 6, lost 16 in other words nine points out of a possible 69 compared with 23 in 2010-11. This was the second lowest away points since three points were introduced in 1981 – the worst was in 1999-2000 when only seven points were gained, but from 19 away trips. Next season we will be visiting our ultimate bogey ground, Preston, again. We have never won a league game there. The run of 20 away games without a win was just two short of the modern record set in 1999-2000 when they went the whole season without an away win. The run of 10 away defeats was the worst by the club since 1929-30 and one short of the all-time club record set in 1925-26.

Wins: City won only nine games in total – one more than the record set in 1995-96 and equalled in our Premier League relegation season (2000-01) but it is the club’s lowest in a 46-game season.

Defeats: The Southampton defeat was the 24th of the season and set a new club record, ‘beating’ the 22 suffered in previous relegation seasons (1924-25 and 1951-52) as well as 1984-85 and 2006-07.

Biggest win:  The team failed to beat anyone by more than a two-goal margin therefore the biggest win of the season was the 3-1 victory over Middlesbrough in January. For the second season running they failed to score more than three goals in a game.

Biggest defeat: Despite City’s lowly position throughout the season nobody thrashed them apart from Southampton. The Saints were the only team to score more than three goals against us (4-2 at home and 4-0 away) with the final day hammering counting as our biggest defeat.

Goals: The goals total of 41 tells the story of our season. This was the lowest in the division and only League Two Macclesfield scored less in the Football League. The lack of goals was the single biggest reason why City were struggling all season. It was the club’s lowest goals total in a 42 or 46 game season since 1972-73. This is a strange fact as that was the season we signed Colin Stein and Tommy Hutchison and everybody has rose-tinted memories of that time!  65 goals were conceded was better than six other Championship teams but only once in the last 25 years have City conceded more (75 in 2004-05).

Final position: The final position of 23^rd means that the Sky Blues finished in the top ten only once in eleven years of second tier football. They are the only club, bar long-serving Premiership clubs and recent promotees from the Conference, not to have been promoted or reached the play-offs since the play-offs were introduced in 1987 nor to finish in the top six of a division. 

Leading scorers: Lukas Jutkiewicz and Gary McSheffrey were joint top scorers with 9 goals. The Juke’s all came in the league in 25 games whilst Gary scored eight in the league and one in the FA Cup. 

Doubles: For the first time since 1999-2000 the Sky Blues failed to ‘do’ the double over any team. This is only the third time in the last 25 years this has happened.  Five clubs, Southampton, Leicester, West Ham, Ipswich and Millwall achieved the feat against City. City have played the Saints in almost 50 seasons and this was the first time they have done the double over the Sky Blues.

Appearances: Joe Murphy started every league game but did not complete two games (Derby and Nottm. Forest). His replacement Chris Dunn was unbeaten and has yet to concede a league goal! Murphy is only the third City player to start every league game in a season since City were relegated in 2001 – Westwood in 2009-10 and Keogh in 2010-11 were the others. But for his red card in the penultimate game Richard Keogh would surely have completed a second successive season of playing in every minute of every league game – a great achievement. Six players failed to start a league game but made substitute appearances (Freddy Eastwood, Shaun Jeffers, Chris Dunn, Josh Ruffels, Will Roberts and Joe Henderson).

Players used:  Thirty one players were used in league and cup games. Of the 31, 12 players made their debuts during the season, three of them loan players (Gary Gardner, Alex Nimely and Oliver Norwood) and 11 of them came from the club’s academy – a remarkable achievement by Greg Rioch and his team. In addition to the 31 players used, two more, Lee Burge and Callum Wilson sat on the bench as substitutes but were not used.

Records: Gary McSheffrey reached 238 appearances by the end of the season and is in 33rd place in the all-time chart, level with 1920s legend Jimmy Dougall and close behind players such as Chris Cattlin (239), Alf Wood (246) and Harry Roberts (249). McSheffrey also crept up to 10^th place in the club’s all-time goalscorers list having now scored 70 goals for the club. He is just behind Dion Dublin (72) and George Hudson (75)in the all-time scorers chart. Conor Thomas’ goal at Blackpool made him the fifth youngest City scorer of all-time. Hermann Hreidarsson became the fifth oldest City debutant when he made his debut v Middlesbrough.

Substitutes: Three players each made the most substitute appearances (10).Bigirimana, Platt and Christie. Gary Deegan and Cody McDonald both came off the bench twice to score goals.

Average attendance: Home 15,121 (2010-11 16,307), down 7.2%. Away 17,619 (2010-11 16,311), up 8%. The home average attendance was the lowest since the penultimate season at Highfield Road, in 2003-04 when the average was 14,632. The away average was boosted by Championship newcomers West Ham and Southampton who both had over 30,000 for City’s visit.

Highest home attendance: The biggest league crowd was 22,240  for the visit of Birmingham City in March.

Lowest home attendance: Only 12,054 attended the midweek visit of Crystal Palace in March – the lowest league crowd at the Ricoh and the lowest City home league gate since September 2004 when 11,968 went through the Highfield Road turnstiles for the visit of Gillingham. The Reading home game in September attracted 12,309 – the lowest for a Saturday home game since the stadium opened in 2005.

Highest away attendance: The biggest away crowd was at West Ham’s Upton Park on New Years Day – 34,936. On the final day of the season a ground record crowd of 32,363 watched City at the St Mary’s Stadium. I believe this is the first time City have set a ground record crowd at a League ground since they played at Torquay in the FA Cup in 1948.

Lowest away attendance: 8,426 v Doncaster. Expect many crowds lower than this next season.

Won from behind: (0) For the second season running City failed to come from behind to win a game all season. The last time the Sky Blues came from behind was at Watford in September 2009 and you have to go back to January 2009 (v Blackpool) for last winning home comeback. On six occasions they did concede the first goal but won a point.

Lost from in front: (7)  Crystal Pal (a), Burnley (h), West Ham (h), Blackpool (a), Ipswich (h), Bristol City (a) plus Southampton (FAC h). In a further five games City took the lead only to be pegged back for draws.

Hat-tricks: (0) No City player scored a hat-trick , in fact only one, Gary McSheffrey, managed more than one goal in a game, versus Leeds and they were both penalties.

Opposing hat-tricks: (0) None. Darius Henderson (Millwall), Michael Chopra (Ipswich), Emile Siclair (Peterborough), Andy Gray (Barnsley) and Ryan Lowe all scored two in a game.

Own goals: For City: (3) Matthew Bates (Middlesbrough h), Liam Cooper (Hull a) and Jon Stead (Bristol City a). Jon Stead scored at both ends, the first time this has happened in a City game since Luton’s Croatian Ahmet Brkovic did it in City’s 3-1 defeat at Kenilworth Road in December 2006.

Own goals: By City: (3) Cranie (Ipswich a), Keogh (Brighton a) and McDonald (Cardiff a).

Penalties: For City: (4) Jutkiewicz, Clingan and McSheffrey (2) scored from the spot. Three penalties were missed: Jutkiewicz (Reading h), Clingan (Leicester a) and McSheffrey (Millwall h) .

Penalties: Against City: (4) Gray (Barnsley a), Halford (Portsmouth a), Ambrose (Crystal Palace h) and Hayter (Doncaster h).  Noel Hunt (Reading h), Lee Martin (Ipswich h) and Neil Danns (Leicester a). Danns also missed a penalty against City in 2010-11 whilst playing for Crystal Palace. Murphy saved Martin’s effort but could not stop Chopra scoring the rebound.

Fastest Goal scored: 2 minutes: Gary McSheffrey scored in the second minute of the home game with Reading in September.

Fastest Goal conceded: 3 minutes: Peterborough’s Emile Sinclair in the game at the Ricoh in April.

Red cards: Coventry: (3) Baker (Leicester h), Bigirimana (Burnley h) and Keogh (Doncaster h)..

Red cards: Opponents: (6) Vassell (Leicester h), Thomson & Arca (Middlesbrough h), Konchesky (Leicester a), Mutch (Birmingham h) and Pitman (Bristol City a). In four of these five games City failed to beat their 10-man opponents.

Television: City appeared on live television three times, at home to Derby (Sky) and away to Ipswich (Sky) and Southampton (BBC).

Cup form: City were unable to win a single Cup tie in 2011-12 – the first time the club have gone out at the first hurdle in both competitions since 1992-93 when they lost to Norwich in the FA Cup and Scarborough in the League Cup. Next season City will play in the First Round of the FA Cup for the first time since 1963 and be unseeded in the League Cup first round.

Man of the Match: The final tally of Andy Turner’s Man of the Match awards was: Jutkiewicz and Keogh 6 each; McSheffrey, Clingan, Norwood and Nimely 4 each.

Miscellany: Cov Kids: On Saturday at Southampton the Sky Blues starting line up contained four Coventry-born players –I believe this is the first time this has happened in the club’s league history. Earlier in the season, against Southampton at home, the game finished with four Cov kids on the pitch but we have never seen it in a starting eleven. The four were Jordan Clarke, Jordan Willis, Conor Thomas and the ‘old man’ Gary McSheffrey.

Youngest ever team: Lots of readers assumed that the team at Southampton must have been the club’s youngest ever. I can confirm it wasn’t. Geoff Moore keeps records of such happenings and told me the average age of the side that finished the game (which was slightly younger than the eleven who started) was 22.9 years whereas the record youngest was in 1980 at Manchester City with an average age of 21.2. Despite all the youngsters in the current side, Murphy and Baker are 30 and 29 respectively, whereas the oldest member of the 1980 side was Harry Roberts at 25.

My column has now finished for the season and apologies to anyone whose questions I haven’t answered, I will hold them over until August. If you have any questions please email me at clarriebourton@gmail.com

With many thanks to Paul O’Connor and Kevin Monks.

Jim's column 28.4.12

                                                         Bobby McDonald - 160 consecutive games       

Coventry City’s relegation to League One (or Division Three) was confirmed with the home defeat to Doncaster Rovers last Saturday – a sad conclusion to a miserable season. Today the injury-ravaged team travel to Southampton’s St Mary’s Stadium to try and recover some pride against the team most likely to follow Reading to the Premier League.

Coventry City have now been relegated four times in their League history. Ian Harris wrote in and wanted to know if in our previous relegations (1925, 1952 and 2001) we were relegated on the final day. In 1925 it was a 0-0 home draw with Derby in the penultimate game which sealed City’s relegation from the old Division Two. Coincidentally, the final game was at Southampton and the team lost 0-3. In 1952 their fate was settled on the last day with a 1-3 loss at Elland Road. In 2001, as many fans will remember it was the 2-3 defeat at Villa Park in the penultimate game which ended City’s hopes of retaining their Premier League status.

City fans will be glad to see the back of one of the worst seasons ever statistically but unfortunately I will have to do my statistical review next week when the season has finally ended.

Poor Richard Keogh saw his tremendous run of City appearances ended in the most unfortunate circumstances last Saturday - with a red card for giving away a penalty. He had played 90 complete league games without missing a single minute and looked set to be an ever-present for the second successive season, something not achieved by a City player since Oggy in the 1990s and by an outfield player since Bobby McDonald in the late 1970s. When the story of City’s time in the Championship is written Richard will be remembered as one of the big-hearted heroes of the era. The ovation he received as he left the pitch was memorable but fully deserved and acclaimed his excellent consistency over the last two seasons. He misses today’s game and City fans fear his form will have made him a target for Premiership or Championship clubs in the coming close season. Let’s hope he is still here come August to lead the club to promotion.

Many City fans (especially ones who travel away) have told me that they are looking forward to visiting lots of new grounds next season and I thought I would look at the likely trips we have next season. Promotion, relegation and play-off issues are still to be resolved in Leagues 1 and 2 (or Divisions 3 & 4 as I prefer to call them) but it is interesting to look at the definite, probable and possible opponents.

Definites – these 14 clubs will definitely face the Sky Blues next season.

Portsmouth

Doncaster

Brentford

Colchester*

Tranmere*

Bury

Bournemouth*

Hartlepool*

Preston

Yeovil*

Scunthorpe

Oldham

Swindon

Shrewsbury*

Several of these clubs have been in the same division as City in recent years (Pompey, Doncaster, Colchester, Preston & Scunthorpe, but City have not met Brentford, Tranmere, Bury, Bournemouth and Shrewsbury in league games since the 1960s. You have to go back to 1958-59 for the last league trip to Hartlepool when 4,032 saw the final game of City’s Fourth Division promotion season.  City will face Yeovil for the first time in a competitive game. The six teams marked with an asterisk are either new or totally reconstructed since the City’s last visit, with Colchester, Yeovil & Shrewsbury new grounds.

Probables  - these clubs have an outside chance of either being relegated or making the play-offs but will probably face the Sky Blues next season.

Leyton O*

Walsall

Notts Co

Carlisle

Crawley*

City will face Sussex club Crawley for the first time in League football and Leyton Orient’s ground has been totally reconstructed since City’s last league visit in 1966.

Possibles – these are the clubs who still have an outside chance of being relegated or those involved in the play-offs.

Sheff Wed

MK Dons*

Huddersfield*

Stevenage*

Torquay

Southend

Cheltenham*

Crewe

Oxford*

Gillingham

Sheff United

There is a strong chance that both Sheffield clubs will be promoted to the Championship and this would make Coventry, arguably, the biggest club in the division. If that was the case then City would face MK Dons, Huddersfield and probably Stevenage – all three at grounds never visited before by the Sky Blues in league action. Cheltenham and Oxford have outside chances of reaching the League Two play-offs and both grounds would be a first for City fans. Stevenage, Cheltenham and MK Dons (if you ignore their dubious claim to Wimbledon’s history) would all be playing the Sky Blues for the first time in their history whilst City have not played Torquay in league action since 1961-62 nor Huddersfield since the Terriers were in the old Division One, and played at Leeds Road, in 1971-72.

As a postcript to the obituary of Jack Evans last week I would like to thank Jack’s neighbour Mrs Margaret Skinner and friend John Green for ensuring that Jack’s wonderful scrapbook was donated to the Coventry City archives. The scrapbook tells Jack’s career story wonderfully and gives a great insight to football from a golden age. It also reminded me of my first ever visit to Highfield Road in 1962 when my father took me to watch Lockheed Leamington beat Rugby Town 5-1 to lift the Birmingham Senior Cup and Jack scored two goals. Ken Brown, a former playing colleague of Jack’s at Coventry and Lockheed, sent me a simple email: ‘Read your piece about Jack Evans. My own little tribute to him, in two words, ‘a Wonderful Man’.

Jim's column 21.4.12

                                                  Jack Evans in his playing days

                                        Jack leads off the old boys at Legends Day 2007

It is with great sadness that I have to report the death of former Coventry City footballer Jack Evans. Jack who was 86 a few weeks ago was on City’s books between 1942-52 and was a regular in the reserve team for several seasons and made eight first team appearances between 1949-51. After leaving City in 1952 he had a long and successful career in local non-league football, playing at a high standard until the age of 36. He died suddenly after being taken ill on the golf course at Maxstoke Park last Sunday morning.

Born in Coventry on 11 March 1926, Jack was just too young to be called up for World War 2 but did his National Service in the army just after hostilities ended and was an accomplished glider pilot. He was signed by City after he wrote in asking for a trial and impressed the management staff. He played centre-forward and wing-half for Modern Machines (City’s Youth team) and in April 1949 after some good performances for the reserves he got his first team chance when injury ruled out Ted Roberts. The opponents in a Second Division match were Fulham at Highfield Road and a few years ago he told me the story. He was getting changed in the dressing room before the kick-off and the tannoy announcer gave the team changes. He read out’ “Number 9 – Jack Evans” only to be greeted by a chorus of boos. Jack however had the last laugh, scoring the only goal of the game against the side who would be promoted later that month.

Nemo in the Coventry Evening Telegraph was complimentary about the new boy:

‘Evans is the nearest thing to (Ted) Roberts on the City books. Lionhearted, not knowing what it is to be beaten, he did the job entrusted to him with real credit. It was a joy to observe his 100% enthusiasm and get a goal’.

The following week, with Roberts fit again, it was back to the ‘stiffs’ and it was the following season (1949-50) before he got another opportunity.  He made three appearances that season, two home 0-0 draws (v QPR and Preston) and a 0-1 defeat at Cardiff. 1950-51 was a good season for Coventry City – they were in the Second Division promotion hunt until the last few weeks of the season, in fact they led the table at the turn of the year. Ted Roberts was a virtual ever-present but when he was injured Jack made four appearances without finding the net:

Leicester (h)  won 2-1

Preston (a) drew 1-1

Cardiff (a) lost 1-2

Cardiff (h) won 2-1

Manager Harry Storer signed ace scorer Tommy Briggs the following week and Jack’s first team days were over.

Jack told me about a friendly game he played in in 1950 against the Turkish side Galatasaray at Highfield Road. They were probably one of the first Turkish sides to visit England and, according to the Coventry Evening Telegraph report, they created a wonderful friendly atmosphere at Highfield Road by carrying the Union Jack on to the pitch and throwing bunches of flowers to the crowd. A crowd of 9,350 saw City win 2-1with goals from Jack and Noel Simpson. Jack told me that the Turks were extremely sporting on the pitch, and they picked City players up when they fell down. Then in the second half, when Ken Chisholm was floored, he was picked up, had his hand shaken and was embraced by the Galatasaray player!

Jack obviously realised he wasn’t going to be a top-class footballer and whilst on City’s books he worked at Daimler and trained to be a carpenter, playing football as a part-time professional. Later he worked at Rolls Royce at Anstey where he was also involved in union duties. He told me that in those days he could earn more as a skilled carpenter than playing football full-time.

In May 1952 he was released by City and joined Nuneaton Borough and the following season had short spells with them and also appeared for Bedworth and Rugby Town. He was back with Bedworth for the 1953-54 season but by March 1954 he was appearing for Banbury Spencer and was playing at outside right.

In 1957 he joined Lockheed Leamington, where his former City colleague Les Latham was manager, and also a favourite grazing place for ex-City men. He played alongside several former City colleagues including Charlie Timmins, Ken Jones, Ken Brown and Mick Lane.

Moving back to wing-half he played his part in Lockheed’s golden era in the early 1960s and won championship medals in 1961-62 and 1962-63. In 1962 he returned to Highfield Road at centre-forward in the Brakes team that lifted the Birmingham Senior Cup by defeating Rugby Town 5-1 in what was my first ever visit to Highfield Road. Jack scored twice and winger Ernie Ward (a former City apprentice) scored a hat-trick. As a young boy I remember Jack leading the Brakes’ forward line and winning virtually every ball in the air with his bald head!

Jack hung up his boots in 1963 at the age of 37 and was assistant manager at Leamington for a time before being granted a testimonial against Nottingham Forest in 1964 for his service to the club.

Jack was a keen golfer and played regularly until his death. After growing up in Cheylesmore he lived in Duncroft Avenue, Coundon for many years. In 2007 he attended the inaugural Legends Day but told me then that he was disillusioned by the modern game and had no interest in coming regularly to City games. According to his old friend John Green, who played with Jack in the Modern Machines team after the war, Jack didn’t even watch football on the television.

A date for his funeral has not been announced at the time of going to press.

Thanks to Paul O’Connor, Paul Vanes and John Green for their assistance in preparing this obituary.

Jim's column 14.4.12

                                         Coventry's 1987 FA Youth Cup winning team

After Monday’s defeat at Ashton Gate in the ‘Game of Death’ the chances of City surviving are slim. An Easter weekend that had begun with so much hope and City looking favourites to avoid the drop, ended with City back in the bottom three and four points adrift of safety. They definitely missed a trick on Saturday afternoon – there was an opportunity against Peterborough to pile more pressure on Bristol, playing late at Nottingham Forest. Instead news of the 2-2 draw at the Ricoh probably galvanised Bristol and they fought a strong rearguard action to grab all three points against an inconsistent Forest.

City may have only lost one of their last ten home games – a remarkable record in the circumstances – but three of the last four have been draws and right now draws are not enough. In all three games City had enough chances and probably deserved to win. At the end of the season they could be the lost points which will send the club down.

City’s seven-game unbeaten run ended in the rain at Ashton Gate on Monday afternoon – it was the longest run since the autumn of 2003 when in the latter days of the McAllister reign the side drew seven in an eight match run without defeat.

Former City loanee Jon Stead scored at both ends, the first time this has happened in a City game since Luton’s Croatian Ahmet Brkovic did it in City’s 3-1 defeat at Kenilworth Road in December 2006.

The last time a Coventry City player scored at both ends was Dave Busst in a thrilling League Cup tie against Spurs in 1995-96 season. Before that you have to go back to the memorable night in 1981 that City beat West Ham 3-2 in the League Cup semi final first leg. City’s hero that night was Garry Thompson who recovered from scoring a first half own goal to score twice at the right end. By a strange coincidence on both these occasions City came from 0-2 to win 3-2.

I have an apology to make to Jack ‘Highfield Road’ Foster. I have just found a letter sent to me by Jack some months ago. He had four questions for me:

1. What is the lowest points total of a club relegated from the championship?
2. What is the lowest number of goals scored by a championship club?
3. Do you reckon Andy Thorn should be the new ‘Mayor of Coventry’ if we avoid relegation?
4. Do you reckon leaving Highfield Road was a disaster?

The answers are:

1. Since the number of games increased to 46 in 1988-89 the lowest total points has been 26, by Stockport County in 2001-02.
2. 31 by Birmingham City in 1988-89.
3. If he pulls us out of this mess, yes!
4. Yes. I think there is a gypsy’s curse on the stadium. We have only finished in the top half once in seven seasons at the Ricoh.

It is 25 years since the Sky Blues’ greatest day - when they won the FA Cup by beating Spurs at Wembley. That same year the club’s youth team won their equivalent, the FA Youth Cup, beating Charlton Athletic in a two-legged final. To commemorate that achievement the Former Players Association have organised a reunion of the Youth squad of ‘87 at next Saturday’s final home game against Doncaster Rovers. The majority of the squad are expected to be present including final goalscorer Steve Livingstone, Tony Dobson, the Middleton twins and Howard Clark - all of whom progressed to the first team. In addition we hope to have the coach of the team, Mick Coop - a true Sky Blue legend - and the director in charge of the boys, John Reason, attending the lunch and making an appearance on the pitch at half-time.The boys, who are now in their early 40s, are all excited by the reunion and many will be coming to a City game for the first time in years. Additionally a good number of the Wembley heroes will be at the game as part of their celebrations of the 25^th anniversary of that fabulous day at Wembley.

Jim's column 7.4.12

             1928: Sid Kimpton (left) alongside Jimmy McIntyre (manager) and Arthur Waters (assistant trainer)

Finally at the 20^th time of asking the Sky Blues notched their first away win of the season at Hull City’s KC Stadium last week. Not only does the victory mean the team won’t have the ignominy of going through a whole season without an away win, and emulating the 1999-2000 side, but it greatly improves the chances of the club remaining in the Championship. There is still much work to be done before safety is assured but two successive wins following four draws means the Sky Blues are the form side at the foot of the table.

The six game unbeaten run might only have been worth 10 points but is the longest unbeaten run by a City side for five years. In 2007 Ian Dowie’s arrival as manager sparked a six game unbeaten run with home wins over Southampton, Hull, Wolves and Barnsley and away draws at Norwich and Colchester. The last time the club had a longer unbeaten run was the autumn of 2003 (in the reign of Gary McAllister) when they drew seven and won one in an eight-game run.

I had to check out how the 20 game winless run compared against the club records and it was two short of the modern day record set between April 1999 and August 2000 which covered the whole of the 1999-2000 season. When you go back further however there was some way to go to break the all-time club record of 28 set in 1924-25. The worst ever runs are as follows:

28                Between 2 Jan 1924 and 4 April 1925 (most of the 24-25 relegation season and half the previous season)

25                Between 23 Oct 1954 and 17 Dec 1955.

22                Between 3 Oct 1931 and 5 Nov 1932 (at a time when Clarrie Bourton was breaking all the scoring records)

22                Between 3 April 1999 and 23 Aug 2000 (during the ‘Entertainers’ era of Keane and Hadji)

At the last Diamond Club lunch Gary Clifford asked if I could through some light on the former City trainer from the late 1920s Sid Kimpton who he believed coached the French national side.

Born in 1887, Sid was christened Gabriel Sibley Kimpton but was also known as ‘George’and came from the Watford area. A tall inside-forward, he played all his football for Southampton in the Southern League, making his debut in 1910 and making almost 150 appearances before the First World War as well as many wartime games. Saints’ manager at the time was Jimmy McIntyre who later became Coventry manager and a close friendship developed. After the war Sid was re-signed by Saints but at the age of 33 his playing career was coming to an end.

His coaching career started on the continent and he coached the now defunct DFC

Prague, Polonia Warsaw and KS Cracovia. There was also a spell in Russia where according to Mike Young he was once falsely arrested with his wife in Germany having arrived from Russia for 'smuggling' a box of chocolates after coaching a 'top Moscow club'.

He arrived at Highfield Road in 1928 and worked under manager Jimmy McIntyre but with little success. He left Coventry in the early 1930s, probably after Harry Storer replaced McIntyre in 1931 and in 1934 turned up in France. After taking  coaching sessions for the French FA he was asked to help coach the French national team in that summer’s World Cup in Italy under senior coach Gaston Barreau. Although France were eliminated in the First Round they gave the tournament favourites, Austria, a major shock only losing after extra-time. Kimpton was feted by the French press but went back to his coaching lessons in Paris at the same time becoming the manager of leading club Racing Club Paris, leading them to the French league title in 1936 and to the Coupe de France in 1936 and 1939. In the summer of 1939 he joined Rouen but soon after the start of the war he was imprisoned as a POW and spent several years in a camp near Paris.

After the war he rejoined Rouen and helped them to win the last War championship before joining AS Cherbourg. He spent his later years back in England and died at Leavesden near Watford in 1968.

The picture was taken at Highfield Road around 1928 and shows Kimpton, McIntyre and according to Mike Young, assistant trainer Arthur Waters.

Jim's column 31.3.12

The sixth Annual Legends Day surpassed all expectations with a record 51 former players attending last Saturday’s home win over Portsmouth. Everything went smoothly and the atmosphere in the dining room, on the pitch at half-time and after the game in the G-Casino was electric. So much laughter and a few tears as old friendships were renewed with lots of ex-City players meeting up again after long absences.

The mystery guest and 200^th member of the Former Players Association was former Coventry City and Wales captain Terry Yorath. Terry had not been to the Ricoh Arena before and was mightily impressed with the stadium and facilities. He got giant hugs from his old team-mates such as Barry Powell, Andy Blair and Garry Thompson and got a tremendous ovation from the fans at half-time.

Terry bumped into Coventry property guru Harvey Williams who was responsible for finding Terry and his family a house in Coventry when he signed from Leeds in 1976. Harvey related the story of how his firm showed Terry 25 or more properties over a number of weeks but none of them impressed the Yoraths. Finally Terry took Harvey to Cannon Hill Road, pointed to a house and said ‘that’s where we want to live’. There was only one snag, the club chairman, Jimmy Hill owned the house and his wife, Heather and children lived there. Harvey relayed the news to JH whose reaction was: ‘who’s going to tell Heather she has to move?’ In the end Harvey and Jimmy broke the news to Heather and Harvey found her a new property in Fairlands Park nearby, and Terry and his family spent three happy years in the house. Harvey and Terry reminisced about old times as though they had never been apart.

Terry was one of a number of the guests who were making their first appearance at Legends Day and others included former Assistant Manager Ron Wylie, 80-year old Billy Gray who played in the early 1950s, Dennis Oakes and Peter Denton from the 1960s, 1987 Youth Cup winner Howard Clark and recently retired Marcus Hall who couldn’t believe so many former players could be brought together.

There are so many people to be thanked for Saturday but the committee are grateful to everybody who contributed, by making donations, by giving up their time and by supporting the committee. Everybody involved helped make it a very successful day. To top a great day the Sky Blues won a vital game, and are now unbeaten in six legends days. When Andy Thorn was told this his response was: ‘Can we have a Legends Day every week’.

Mr RA Berry of Holbrooks recently sent me a Coventry City team picture and asked if I could tell him the year it came from. The picture, reproduced here, is of the 1906-07 team and was taken before a match against Wolves Reserves at Highfield Road on 5 January 1907. The Birmingham & District League game was watched by a crowd of around 2,500 and ended 1-1 with Tooth netting for City. Managed by former player Joe Beaman, City were on the verge of making a name for themselves. The following season an excellent FA Cup run took them to the equivalent of the Third Round, and although they lost to Southern League Crystal Palace they came to the attention of many influential people in the football world and in 1908 were elected into the Southern League, then the foremost league outside the Football League.

On Thursday evening I will be at the Herbert Art Gallery and Museum for the launch of the exhibition ‘From Highfield Road to Wembley Way’ commemorating the 25^th anniversary of the club’s Wembley victory. Tickets for the launch, which are free, are available on line at www.herbert.org